Biltham Hall: An MM Romance

by Patrick C. Notchtree

Readers' Reviews and Remarks

All reviews are genuine and unbiased and not influenced by financial or other reward.
REVIEWS

* * * * * * *

4 Stars An enjoyable read which has this really beautiful relationship at its heart
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 13 November 2026
Verified Purchase
An enjoyable read which has this really beautiful relationship at its heart. It depicts the struggles they go through both as a couple and individually. It feels very authentic to the time period and how same sex relationships were viewed in the 1940’s. I found it to be an extremely detailed read but did wonder if there could have been less focus on the world building as 400+ pages makes it quite a substantial read! But overall very enjoyable and different from other MM books out there!
Link to full review New window

You get good value with my books. Lol There was no focus on word building. I go where the story takes me. For example, Albert was nowhere in the original plan, but along he came. I believe this is what some call character driven writing. They're in charge! - PCN

* * * * * * *

4 Stars Nice story
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 10 November 2026e
Interesting well written
Link to full review New window

* * * * * * *

5 Stars Hard to put down once started!
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 7 November 2026
Verified Purchase
I loved everything about this book. The characters are well written and the pace of the story is spot on.
I read it in one afternoon as I couldn't put it down once I'd started.
I would absolutely love a prequel as there's an obvious back story to be told!

Link to full review New window

* * * * * * *

5 Stars Brillant
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 6 November 2026
Brillant lovely story
Link to full review New window

* * * * * * *

4 Stars The LOVE don't have colour or religion!!!
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 4 November 2026
Biltham Hall is a poignant, detailed historical drama that seamlessly blends WWII history, aristocratic drama, and slow-burn gay romance. It is ideal for readers who enjoy Downton Abbey-style historical settings, post-war British history, and deeply emotional M/M romance stories.
Link to full review New window

* * * * * * *

5 Stars Beautiful Historical Romance That Redefines Love and Family
Reviewed in the United States on November 4, 2026
Patrick C. Notchtree Historical Fiction novel Biltham Hall is an m/m romance that is a touching and moving book that celebrates love in various forms and embraces change for the better.
Lieutenant Commander James Linnel, Viscount Rede DSO RN son and heir for the Earl of Biltham has returned home after WWII. As if the post trauma wasn't enough, he is in mourning for his lover Seaman David Yarridge who was killed in battle. Upon his return, he finds a different world that he has to rebuild from the ground up and a handsome multitalented servant named Jack Milburn who fascinates him. He is attracted to Jack and can't quite shake the feeling that Jack feels the same way.
There are two facets to the book and both compliment each other rather well. They are James's relationship with Jack which flies in the face of British society in the mid-20th century and James changing his home Biltham Hall and his future earldom to become more inclusive, involved, and modern.
Homosexuality in 1940’s Britain was still illegal and could have resulted in imprisonment, separation, exile, ostracism, and disgrace. It is a very huge risk for James and Jack to pursue their attraction to each other. But their relationship is a vibrant egalitarian one that mutually benefits both.
James had always been class conscious but maintained close associations with working and servant class people. That distinction became thinner during the war as he got to know David, who was from a lower status. This personal relationship completely changed James's outlook when the people who worked under him revealed their faces, personalities, goals. Before he saw people lower than him. Afterwards, he just saw people.
Now with Jack, he sees a potential lifetime companion. James is a visionary who looks at Biltham Hall and makes far seeing plans to preserve its future. Jack is the details person who knows what it takes to get the job done. James is idealistic and Jack is practical. Jack needs someone to give him a chance to show off his various skills. James needs someone to carry out his ideas and interpret them in a way that everyone can understand.
James and Jack are a couple who if they existed today would have no barriers towards their union. They would be seen as a perfect couple and #relationship goals. The only things keeping them apart in the 1940’s are the law which is unjust and the class divide which is being redefined. Here, they complete one another and take James's eventual ownership of Biltham Hall seriously.
Biltham Hall does something rather clever and sweet demonstrating tradition and how James and Jack can still use it to their benefit. In many LGBT+ romances, the protagonist is thrown into an unhappy marriage with a horrible opposite sex person in the name of tradition and producing heirs.
Notchtree does not do this. In fact, he takes a unique approach towards the Honorable Isabel “Izzy” Errington daughter of Sir Edward Errington of Craneshaugh and the woman that James's parents want him to marry by making her another terrific character and good person.
Izzy is also able to complement the others and contribute to the changes. She is more outspoken and forthright than the more diffident and accommodating James and the blunt but self-conscious Jack. She becomes the duo’s spokesperson promoting James's ideas and Jack's work to the public as a challenge to a stodgy Conservative reactionary authority.
The other reason that Izzy is so developed is because she understands exactly how James and Jack feel. She is in a lesbian relationship with her friend and companion, Eleanor. Unfortunately Eleanor isn't nearly as developed as the other characters and often just supports the others and chimes in with whatever is going on. But she is a sweet, sometimes dizzy partner to Izzy and is able to smooth out her brash girlfriend’s prickly rough edges. Eleanor is welcomed to the family to the point that the two couples eventually refer to themselves as the Fearless Foursome.
Because of their mutual homosexuality, the quartet redefines marriage, companionship, and eventually family. James, Izzy, and eventually Jack and Eleanor grow to love and respect each other but in platonic brother-sister non sexual ways. They save the romance, beds, private times, and the titles of “husband” and “wife” for the real same sex loves of their lives.
There is another addition to this family that also illustrates James's empathetic progressive nature and willingness to give everyone a chance to be heard, seen, and understood. He is Albert Linnel, James's developmentally disabled cousin who is probably on the Autism Spectrum. He has been institutionalized by his parents and released by James.
The family's unconventional foundation is what helps them understand Albert and his struggles. Since James has been through war, he recognizes the trauma symptoms within Albert because of the institutional abuse directed at him. He tries to help and support the boy with Jack, Izzy, and Eleanor also contributing to the boy's care.
Albert begins to adjust, embrace a talent for art and horse reading and becomes a beautiful addition to this unique family. It is a family of outsiders that form a whole unit. Albert is the son and heir to two sets of loyal, loving, and devoted parents.
While Biltham Hall is a beautiful m/m Historical Romance the best aspect isn't just the romance. It is the relationship between five people who become a non-traditional but loving family.
Link to full review New window

* * * * * * *

5 Stars Good
Reviewed in the United States on November 2, 2026
It was such a good book even though I’m not much of a historical book type of person but I still found it to be good.
Link to full review New window

* * * * * * *

5 Stars Not what I was expecting but still good.
Reviewed in the United States on November 2, 2026e
I picked this book out because I was hoping to get swept away in a love story, but it turned out to be not what I expected. I can say that I did like how the unconventional love story gave everyone a happy ending. While not the traditional love story that I was looking for, I can appreciate how everyone found life partners that allowed them to live their lives to the fullest.
I did love the pictures that were included. I'm a very visual person, so I think that was a nice touch.
Link to full review New window

* * * * * * *

5 Stars Good
Reviewed in the United States on October 29, 2026
Such a good book, will read again.
Link to full review New window

* * * * * * *

3 Stars Okay. Ish.
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 26 October 2026
A heartwarming story that captures the audience, but I feel it spends too much time focusing on the history of 1945.
Link to full review New window

I feel the post-war setting in a bombed and battered Britain with its wide class divides and restrictive social mores is fundamental to the story. - PCN

* * * * * * *

5 Stars Beautiful Historical MM Romance!
Reviewed in the United States on October 25, 2026e
Biltham Hall by Patrick C. Notchtree was such an enjoyable read! I loved the historical setting, the romance, and the emotions woven throughout the story. The characters were interesting, and I enjoyed watching their relationship develop. A lovely mix of history, love, and heartfelt moments. Definitely worth picking up if you enjoy MM historical romance!
Link to full review New window

* * * * * * *

5 Stars Biltham Hall
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 22 October 2026
What a moving and emotionally powerful story! Set in post-war Britain, this book sounds like a beautiful yet heartbreaking exploration of forbidden love, class prejudice, and the impossible choices people faced in a society ruled by rigid expectations. My heart goes out to James and Jack, who must hide their love in a world that refuses to accept them. The added themes of grief, family duty, and the treatment of vulnerable people make this story feel even more poignant. I love the promise of hope shining through the sadness, and I can imagine this being a deeply affecting read that stays with you long after the final page.
Link to full review New window

* * * * * * *

5 Stars Ok
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 22 October 2026e
This is agood book with a nice warm romantic feel. However it wasnt for me I prefer present day storie
Link to full review New window

The website and the blurb makes it clear when the book is set. - PCN

* * * * * * *

5 Stars Love Behind the Walls of Tradition
Reviewed in the United States on October 21, 2026
The post-war setting adds so much emotional depth to this story of love, duty, and social expectations. James’s struggle between his family’s demands and his feelings for Jack creates a compelling tension, while the crumbling estate reflects a society beginning to change. I also appreciate the inclusion of his young autistic cousin’s situation, which adds another difficult layer to the story. A moving historical romance about courage, secrecy, and hope in a world that refuses to make love easy.
Link to full review New window

* * * * * * *

5 Stars Ok I love it
Reviewed in the United States on October 21, 2026
Biltham Hall: An MM Romance by Patrick C. Notchtree looks like a captivating read! I love the historical setting, the beautiful cover, and the promise of romance, mystery, and emotional depth. The combination of wartime history and romance makes this book especially intriguing. Biltham Hall looks like the perfect setting for a story filled with unexpected connections, heartfelt moments, and unforgettable characters. A wonderful choice for readers who enjoy historical MM romance with a unique atmosphere. Highly recommended!
Link to full review New window

* * * * * * *

4 Stars Lovely read
Reviewed in the United States on October 21, 2026
Very lovely read! I enjoyed the writing and enjoyed that they would add a few pictures, though it sort of felt like i was reading a textbook whenever a picture was present. That did not take away from the lovely writing though.
Link to full review New window

I'm sorry you found the pictures distracting. I thought they might help readers, particularly those not familiar with the UK, to better visualize the events. I'm glad you liked the story. - PCN

* * * * * * *

5 Stars A Refreshing Mix of Romance and WWII History
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 21 October 2026
*Biltham Hall* by Patrick C. Notchtree is a story about love, war, and life during World War II. I enjoyed the mix of history, romance, and humour. I liked the characters and wanted to know what would happen next. Overall, I enjoyed reading this book and would recommend it to anyone who likes stories about history and romance.
Link to full review New window

* * * * * * *

4 Stars Quietly Radical Love Story Set in the Long Shadow of the War
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 21 October 2026
Biltham Hall by Patrick C. Notchtree is an MM historical romance set in mid-1940s England, following James, the new Lord Biltham, as he returns from the Navy to restore his crumbling estate and finds himself drawn into an unexpected and tender relationship with Albert, a young man whose traumatic past has left him profoundly different from anyone James has ever met. Notchtree writes with patience and warmth, taking real time with the textures of postwar rural England: the estate management, the German prisoner workers on the home farm, the class dynamics of the village, and the quiet impossibility of loving another man in an era when doing so was a criminal act. The relationship between James and Albert develops with genuine delicacy, particularly in the scenes where James slowly learns how to understand Albert’s way of being in the world, and the emotional payoff of those moments is considerable. At 475 pages this is an unhurried, immersive read that rewards those who settle into its rhythms, recommended for readers who love quiet historical fiction with real humanity at its centre.
Link to full review New window

Perhaps this was written from memory as the reader seems to have confused some of the characters. - PCN